[Moon] Fwd: Re: [Moon-Net] WHAT MAKES A QSO VALID WITH WSJT

[ok1teh Petrzilka]

Hi all,
It's simple, for valid QSO you must exchange both callsign
and final RGR (in any mode or propagation). If somebody
is calling 2nd station (which is running CQ) with OOO
and that 2nd station answer with ST "RO", QSO is not valid.

If that CQ station answer with both callsign + RO (not ST),
QSO should be considered as valid but it's not optimal way
because you'll lose advantage of ST MSG. My opinion is,
that "CQ station" should answer on such a wrong OOO msg
with OOO too. After that OP from 1st station with OOO will see
that there was a problem, but he will answer RO and after
RRR QSO is completed in proper way. QRZ in WSJT is possible
and oftenly used (of course) but it's not necessary in such a situation..

73
Matej, OK1TEH



---------- Původní zpráva ----------
Od: Lars Pettersson <sm4ive at telia.com>
Komu: moon at moonbounce.info <moon at moonbounce.info>
Datum: 23. 11. 2014 10:16:01
Předmět: [Moon] Fwd: Re: [Moon-Net] WHAT MAKES A QSO VALID WITH WSJT

"







                                                                            
	 
	 
                                                                            
	 
	 
                                                                            
	 
	 
                                                                            
	 
	 
                                                                            
	 
	 


Serge
tha main problem are made by VE1KG  You should not send RO RO   since you 
dont know who is calling you. you should send QRZ QRZ    if thats possible 
in Dodle mode?
I have folowd the discusion on the other moon reflector and it seems there 
are a BIG Problem and different ways to judge when is a QSO a QSO.
This shows the difference between real EME QSOs   compared to Trace qso :-)

73 Lars SM4IVE

Doug McArthur skrev 2014-11-21 23:38:

" Simple Serge!
You publish all your contacts on Moon net (including the ARRL contest).. get
the corrections.. then tell all you have sent the QSL and all is valid!
And some wonder why the CW guys become some what cynical.
GL 73 Doug


On 22/11/2014 9:23 AM, serge wrote:

" 
>From time to time i call CQ on 144Mhz & from time to time I get a station 
responding sending me 000 so I send RO & they send me RR to which I send 73 
& voila the qso is complete   But is it now!!!! I never sent the station's 
call.   I come from the CW school where you send the call of the station 
calling CQ & your call then he will respond with YOUR call & OOO & then RO 
ect ect both calls have been sent both ways. Why should it be different with
WSJT??? I have problems with this when it happens to me or when I see it 
happening to someone else as to the validity of the QSO

Your comments will be appreciated thank you

73,Serge VE1KG

" 
" 



_______________________________________________
Moon mailing list
Moon at moonbounce.info
http://lists.moonbounce.info/listinfo/moon"
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.moonbounce.info/pipermail/moon/attachments/20141123/fc2650ee/attachment.html>